Coffee and the Enlightenment | Skeleton Brew Coffee

Coffee and the Enlightenment

How the sober drink changed how Europe thought.

If you sat down to breakfast in an English or German household around 1600, nobody would have offered you anything to wake you up. You'd get bread, maybe porridge, and something to drink, and that something was almost always alcoholic. In parts of northern Europe the morning meal was beer soup, warmed and thickened with eggs. Children drank "small beer," a weak brew that was safer than whatever came out of the local well, and adults carried on with beer, wine, or cider for the rest of the day. Nobody was falling over at the breakfast table, but as Tom Standage points out in A History of the World in 6 Glasses, a good part of Europe spent its waking hours in a mild, more or less permanent haze.

Then coffee showed up. It came by way of the Ottoman Empire, where it had been a daily habit for well over a century (helped along by Islam's ban on alcohol), and it did the opposite of everything Europeans were used to drinking. Instead of slowing you down, it sharpened you up. Some historians think that small change in what people drank did more to shape the Enlightenment than we usually give it credit for.

A New Kind of Room

England got its first coffeehouse in Oxford in the early 1650s, and London's opened in 1652, when a Greek-born servant named Pasqua Rosée started selling coffee in St. Michael's Alley in Cornhill. It caught on fast. By the 1730s London had hundreds of coffeehouses, more than 550 by one count. People at the time knew exactly what made the drink different. One verse from the period praised coffee for making "the genius quicker" and lifting the spirits "without making mad," which is about as good a summary of its appeal as you'll find anywhere. You could sit with a cup all afternoon and come out thinking more clearly than when you went in, and for a social drink, that was something new.

The bigger change, though, was the coffeehouse itself. For roughly a penny you got a dish of coffee, a place at a long shared table, the day's newspapers and pamphlets, and whatever conversation happened to be going on around you. Oxford and Cambridge were closed to nearly everyone, but the coffeehouse wasn't, so people took to calling them "penny universities." Some even posted rules on the wall asking customers to keep their arguments civil.

Before long, particular coffeehouses had their own crowds. The Grecian was where members of the Royal Society went to keep talking after their meetings, and Isaac Newton and the astronomer Edmund Halley were both regulars. (There's a much-repeated story, hard to pin down, that the two of them once dissected a dolphin on one of its tables.) The poet John Dryden held court at Will's. At Lloyd's, which Edward Lloyd opened in the 1680s, ship owners and merchants swapped shipping news and eventually started insuring each other's cargoes, and that business grew into Lloyd's of London. Over in Exchange Alley, traders at Jonathan's met to set stock prices, which is why it's usually counted as the beginning of the London Stock Exchange. It's a strange thought that modern insurance and the stock market both got their start over coffee, but that's more or less what happened.

Not Everyone Was a Fan

Coffeehouses had their critics. In 1674 a pamphlet called The Women's Petition Against Coffee complained that men were frittering away their days over the "heathenish liquor," and that it left them as "unfruitful as the sandy deserts" the bean came from. Historians still argue about whether women actually wrote it or whether it was a satire. The reply it provoked, The Men's Answer to the Women's Petition, blamed ale and cheap wine instead and managed to be even ruder. Under the jokes there was a real complaint, though. English coffeehouses were almost entirely male, so the penny university was really only open to men who had a penny.

The more serious trouble came from the King. Charles II suspected the coffeehouses of spreading gossip and sedition, and at the end of 1675 he issued a Proclamation for the Suppression of Coffee Houses, blaming them for "very evil and dangerous effects." It didn't last. Londoners were furious, Parliament showed no interest in backing him, and he withdrew the order in early January 1676, about eleven days after it took effect. Barely a generation after the first one opened, the coffeehouse had become something ordinary people simply weren't willing to give up.

Paris and Leipzig

The French had their own version. In 1686 a Sicilian named Procopio Cutò opened the Café Procope in Paris, on the street where the Comédie-Française would soon set up its theatre. Actors and writers filled the place, and over the following century it counted Voltaire, Rousseau, Diderot, and d'Alembert among its regulars. The story goes that Diderot and d'Alembert first talked through the idea for the Encyclopédie, their enormous attempt to gather all human knowledge into one work, at its tables. Benjamin Franklin and Thomas Jefferson both stopped in during their time in Paris. Voltaire is supposed to have drunk dozens of cups of coffee a day; the number has probably grown each time someone repeats it, but he was clearly fond of the stuff. The Procope is still open, and you can still have dinner there.

In Leipzig in the 1730s, Johann Sebastian Bach wrote what we now call the Coffee Cantata, a comic piece about a father who threatens to keep his daughter from marrying unless she gives up coffee. She isn't having it. The cantata was performed by a music society that met at Zimmermann's coffeehouse, so the audience was presumably drinking the very thing being sung about.

So, Did Coffee Cause the Enlightenment?

Probably not on its own, though it makes for a good argument. The German historian Wolfgang Schivelbusch, in Tastes of Paradise, sees coffee as the drink of a rising middle class that prized sobriety, discipline, and hard work, which made it a natural replacement for beer at breakfast. Standage goes a step further and suggests that the switch from alcohol to caffeine helped pull Western Europe out of its haze. The philosopher Jürgen Habermas, coming at it from another direction, pointed to coffeehouses as one of the first places where a "public sphere" took shape, with private people getting together to argue about public affairs.

The trouble is that the Enlightenment had plenty of other causes, including the printing press, rising literacy, and a scientific revolution that was already well under way before anyone in London had tasted coffee. Not every coffeehouse was a seminar room, either. Plenty of them were loud, gossipy, and a bit disreputable. In Britain, tea had overtaken coffee by the middle of the 1700s, and private clubs and cheaper newspapers gradually took over the jobs coffeehouses used to do. Our own take is that coffee didn't produce the ideas, but it did a lot to produce the places where people argued about them. It gave people a sober reason to get together, it cost almost nothing to get in the door, and it kept everyone awake long enough to keep talking.

Your Own Coffee Corner

We think about this a lot at Skeleton Brew, because the best thing about those old coffeehouses was never just the coffee. It was what the coffee made room for. You don't need a seat at the Grecian to get some of that back. A good cup at your kitchen table, a book you keep meaning to finish, or a friend who likes arguing about history will do the job nicely, and that's a big part of why we built Coffee Corner, to help you set up a cozy third place of your own at home. It's also why $1 from every bag of Skeleton Brew goes to public media. Public broadcasting is about as close as we get these days to a penny university: news and knowledge open to anyone who wants to listen, no tuition required.

Further Reading

  • Tom Standage, A History of the World in 6 Glasses (2005)
  • Wolfgang Schivelbusch, Tastes of Paradise: A Social History of Spices, Stimulants, and Intoxicants (1992)
  • Markman Ellis, The Coffee-House: A Cultural History (2004)
  • Jürgen Habermas, The Structural Transformation of the Public Sphere (1962; English translation 1989)

So the next time you pour your morning cup, spare a thought for the people who fought a king to keep drinking it. Three and a half centuries ago that same drink was helping to start insurance markets and keep Newton up arguing about the universe, which isn't bad for a roasted bean. Brew something good, and then go think about something interesting.

Back to blog